Publication date: 23.05.2024
Appeals in criminal proceedings
Impeachment in criminal proceedings is a procedural action, which consists in excluding a certain person from participating in the case due to the presence of circumstances that may cause doubts about his impartiality and objectivity. The challenge may concern a judge, an investigator, a prosecutor, an expert, a secretary of a court session, an interpreter, or other participants in the process.
Grounds for withdrawal include:
- 1. Conflict of interest:
- A person has a personal interest in the outcome of the case or a close relationship with one of the parties.
- 2. Previous participation in the case:
- The person has already participated in this proceeding in another role (for example, the judge was previously an investigator in this case).
- 3. Family or other close relationships:
- The person is a relative or has other close relations with the participants of the proceedings, which may affect his impartiality.
- 4. Reasonable suspicion of bias:
- There are specific circumstances that may raise doubts about a person's impartiality and objectivity.
Withdrawal procedure
- 1. Application for recusal:
- A party to a criminal proceeding (accused, suspect, defense attorney, prosecutor) submits an appeal to the relevant body (court).
- 2. Consideration of the application:
- The application for revocation is considered by the body whose competence includes the resolution of the question of revocation. For example, the impeachment of a judge is considered by the same court, but by a different judge.
- 3. Resolution of the issue of recusal:
- After considering the application, a decision is made to accept or reject the appeal. If the challenge is satisfied, the person is removed from participation in the case and replaced by another person who has no grounds for challenge.
The role of the lawyer in ensuring impartial consideration of the case
The participation of a lawyer in the process of impeachment of an investigator, prosecutor or judge during the defense of his client - a suspect or an accused - is an important component of ensuring a fair trial and protection of the client's rights. A lawyer plays a key role in identifying and filing recusal applications, as well as in supporting this process.
The role of the lawyer in the appeal process:
- 1. Identification of grounds for revocation:
- The lawyer analyzes the circumstances of the criminal proceedings and the relationship of the investigator, prosecutor or judge with other participants in the process in order to identify possible grounds for recusal.
- The lawyer pays attention to conflicts of interest, personal interest, previous involvement in the case and other circumstances that may affect impartiality and objectivity.
- 2. Preparation of the appeal statement:
- The lawyer prepares a motivated application for recusal, where he cites specific grounds and justification for the need to recusal the investigator, prosecutor or judge.
- The statement must include all the circumstances that raise doubts about the impartiality and objectivity of the person in question.
- 3. Submission of an application for revocation:
- The lawyer submits an application for recusal to the relevant body or official who has the authority to consider such applications (investigating judge, head of the pre-trial investigation body, superior prosecutor).
- 4. Protection of the client's position during application consideration:
- The lawyer participates in the consideration of the application for recusal, representing and defending the position of his client.
- The lawyer can provide additional evidence and arguments to confirm the validity of the application for recusal.
- 5.Appealing decisions on revocation:
- If the application for recusal was rejected, the lawyer can appeal this decision in accordance with the established procedure.
- The lawyer will prepare an appeal and represent the client's interests in higher authorities.
The importance of a lawyer's participation:
- - Ensuring the client's rights:
The lawyer ensures that the rights of the suspect or the accused to a fair trial and an impartial investigation are respected.
- - Prevention of violations:
The lawyer contributes to the detection and prevention of possible violations of procedural norms and conflicts of interest.
- - Professional support:
The lawyer provides professional legal support to the client, helping to navigate complex procedural issues and protect their interests.
Recusal is an important mechanism for ensuring fair and impartial consideration of the case, prevention of conflicts of interest and compliance with the principle of objectivity in criminal proceedings.
The participation of a lawyer in the recusal process is an integral part of the legal defense of the suspect or the accused, contributing to ensuring the fairness and impartiality of the criminal proceedings.
- Legal service "Consultant" provides legal assistance in any situation. Our lawyers will carry out a legal analysis of the situation, make a comprehensive analysis of documents, prepare a legal opinion and ensure the representation of the client's interests in state authorities or a court, will take part in a court hearing in any city of Ukraine. Consulting a lawyer and legal protection by a lawyer is a guarantee of quality protection of your rights and interests.
Legal service "Consultant" provides the service "lawyer's help online".
