Publication date: 03.06.2024
What is judicial debate in a criminal case?
Court debate in a criminal case is a stage of the judicial process that takes place after the examination of evidence and the conduct of all procedural actions related to the consideration of the case. During court debates, the parties present their final arguments, summarize the evidence, and provide their legal opinions.
Which participants in criminal proceedings have the right to speak in court debates?
The following participants have the right to participate in court debates in criminal proceedings:
- Prosecutor: presents the prosecution on behalf of the state.
- Accused (defendant): a person who is accused of committing a criminal offense.
- Defender of the accused: a lawyer representing the interests of the accused.
- Victim: a person who suffered as a result of a criminal offense.
- Representative of the victim: a lawyer or other authorized person representing the interests of the victim.
- Civil plaintiff: a person who filed a civil lawsuit within the framework of criminal proceedings.
- Representative of the civil plaintiff: a lawyer or other authorized person representing the interests of the civil plaintiff.
- Civil defendant: a person responsible for a civil claim within the framework of criminal proceedings.
- Representative of the civil defendant: a lawyer or other authorized person representing the interests of the civil defendant.
Main aspects of judicial debate:
- Presentation of the parties: Each party presents its final arguments, based on the examined evidence.- Evidence analysis: The parties summarize the evidence supporting their position and analyze the opponent's evidence.
- Legal conclusions: The parties provide their legal conclusions, justifying the legality of their position.
- Closing speeches: The prosecutor and defense counsel conclude by expressing their views on the guilt or innocence of the accused.
Can new evidence be presented in court debates?
New evidence is not usually allowed in court debates. Court debates are intended for the final discussion of the evidence already presented and examined in the case. However, if the court decides that the previously provided evidence requires additional research or the need for new evidence has arisen for a full and comprehensive consideration of the case, it may make a decision to renew the investigation of the circumstances and research of new evidence.
Can the court limit the length of speech in court debates? If so, in what cases?
The court has no right to limit the duration of court debates to a specific time. However, the presiding officer may stop the speech of a participant in the debate if, after the remark, he again goes beyond the limits of the criminal proceedings or repeatedly allows offensive or obscene statements, and give the floor to another participant.
However, such restrictions must be justified and not violate the rights of the participants to a fair trial. The court must ensure that all participants have sufficient time to present their positions and arguments.
Court debates conclude with the defendant's final speech, after which the court goes to the deliberation room for a verdict.
Conclusion
Court debates are an important part of the criminal trial, providing participants with an opportunity to summarize the evidence and arguments presented during the trial.
Professional legal assistance to the accused is of particular importance in court debates. A qualified defense attorney helps summarize the case, focusing on the defense's persuasive arguments, which can be critical to the outcome of the case. The exchange of remarks between the participants of the debate, with the right of the last remark for the accused or his defender, provides an opportunity to respond to the arguments of opponents and additionally strengthen their position. This highlights the importance of careful preparation and a professional approach to court debates, which have a significant impact on the court's final decision.
Legal service "Consultant" provides legal assistance in any situation. Our lawyers will carry out a legal analysis of the situation, make a comprehensive analysis of documents, prepare a legal opinion and ensure the representation of the client's interests in state authorities or a court, will take part in a court hearing in any city of Ukraine. Consulting a lawyer and legal protection by a lawyer is a guarantee of quality protection of your rights and interests.
Legal service "Consultant" provides the service "lawyer's help online".
