See more
Publication date: 18.05.2024
The commercial court of the Dnipropetrovsk region satisfied the claims of Ukrainian companies against the russian federation for property damage: new decisions in favor of war victims
The Commercial Court of the Dnipropetrovsk region recently made two important decisions, satisfying the claims of Ukrainian enterprises against the Russian Federation for property damage caused as a result of military aggression. Both decisions, which have entered into legal force and have not been challenged in the appeal or cassation procedure, are important precedents in Ukrainian justice and demonstrate the desire to compensate for the damage caused by Russia's aggression.
The case of PP of the company "Oktan"
The first case concerns the lawsuit of the private enterprise of the firm "Oktan" against the russian federation (case No. 904/1907/23). According to the press service of the court, the court found that as a result of the rocket attack by the russian rederation in the city of Kryvyi Rih, the property of the plaintiff was destroyed or damaged, in particular, six tanks together with connecting pipelines, which were used to store fuel.
The commercial court partially satisfied the lawsuit of the PP company "Oktan" and recovered from the Russian Federation UAH 64,848,659.58 in property damage, UAH 90,000 in costs for conducting a technical survey of the destroyed property, as well as UAH 140,000 in costs for conducting an assessment of actual damages. This decision was a significant step in compensating for the damages caused by Russia's aggression and showed the effectiveness of the Ukrainian legal system in protecting the interests of its citizens and enterprises.The case of "BaDM" LLC
The second case concerns the lawsuit of the limited liability company "BaDM" against the Russian Federation (case No. 904/153/24). The court established that on April 28, 2023, as a result of rocket fire in the city of Dnipro, civil infrastructure was damaged, which led to the death of two people, wounding of two people and significant damage from the blast wave.
The plaintiff, "BaDM" LLC, noted that due to the damage to the infrastructure of the pharmacy warehouse No. 1, the company's activity was practically paralyzed, and its restoration requires significant financial costs, which the company cannot provide on its own. The lack of financial resources of the enterprise is due to active charitable activities, the fulfillment of financial obligations to the state, national and foreign suppliers, as well as the preservation of jobs.
On February 20, 2024, the Commercial Court fully satisfied the claim of BaDM LLC and recovered from the Russian Federation the amount of damages in the amount of UAH 672,176 excluding VAT and UAH 89,000 for conducting an expert assessment of damages caused by missile fire.
The importance of these decisions
Both decisions of the Commercial Court of Dnipropetrovsk region are significant not only for the affected enterprises, but also for the entire legal system of Ukraine. They demonstrate the readiness of Ukrainian courts to protect the rights of their citizens and enterprises, to uphold justice and ensure compensation for damages caused by military aggression.These decisions can also serve as an important precedent for other businesses and citizens who have suffered as a result of Russian aggression, showing that justice can be achieved even in the difficult conditions of war.You may be interested in the following articles: lawyer consultation, lawyer consultation, analysis of documents, legal analysis of the situation, written consultation, verification of documents by a lawyer, lawyers, documents, lawyer's assistance online, lawyer online, legal opinion, legal opinion of a lawyer, lawyer online Legal analysis of the situation, Legal opinion, Writing a lawyer's request, lawyer's request, analysis of the situation by a lawyer, analysis of the situation by a lawyer, lawyer's opinion, lawyer's opinion.
Conclusions
The adopted decisions of the Commercial Court of the Dnipropetrovsk region regarding the satisfaction of the claims of the PP firm "Oktan" and LLC "BaDM" against the Russian Federation are an important step in protecting the rights and interests of Ukrainian enterprises. They emphasize the strength and effectiveness of the Ukrainian judicial system in ensuring justice and compensation for damages caused by the aggressor. These precedents serve as a reminder of the importance of the legal fight to restore justice and may inspire other victims to take active action in protecting their rights.
